- Feb 23, 2015
- 3,860
- 4,255
- 693
omg. you been exploited!Notice they quoted me.. I found it a little ironic they didn't contact me. LOL.
omg. you been exploited!Notice they quoted me.. I found it a little ironic they didn't contact me. LOL.
What profession other than sex work, are the workers depicted as victims, drug addicts, STD spreaders, "damaged" psyche, etc? What other profession is shown in the media, where the workers are routinely found murdered as a joke? It's not about "people made fun of the group I'm a part of!" it's about "hey stop putting dehumanizing shit out there that makes people think it's no big deal to harass and kill people who are part of my group".Hmm, that's an interesting idea. Maybe we show extend that to all professions, only people who've done a job can produce films, books, tv shows etc. about it So only cops can write about cops, politicians about politicians. Same thing for Orca trainers, the mafia, doctors, astronaut, tobacco executives, rapist, humanitarian, rock stars, tech executive, preachers, cowboys, and drug dealers etc. We'd live in much different and dare say less interesting and empathetic world.
I get the anger of being part of a group. that you think is good but suddenly everybody is making fun of your group, calling you stupid, and evil. There is a natural instinct to be suspicious of outsiders and feel like it is us vs them and become more insular Now, I've never been part of something that I was embarrassed to tell my parents about or been called a slut so I'm sure you all have had it worse.
I was a child in the 80's so I have no recollection of sex work ever being acceptable in society, but from what I've read, it seems like the AIDS epidemic in the 80's was a big factor as to why society turned on any/all sex workers. And sex workers HAVE been talking to the media, in documentaries, etc for decades. (Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics, Annie Sprinkle, Carol Leigh, etc) Plus during the 80's we there were multiple notorious serial killers (Robert Hansen, the Green River Killer, the Yorkshire Ripper) who specifically targeted sex workers.. I know you said the stigma wasn't so bad for strippers & pornstars, but many strippers and pornstars also did FSSW...Back in the 1980s, there was far more social stigma to being homosexual, than there was to being a sex worker like a stripper or a porn star. Today that's changed and the stigma of being gay is far less than being a sex worker. The polling data, I've seen suggests that being gay is really not a big deal among young people at all.
Why the shift? I think a huge reason is because Gays came out of the closet. Now they didn't all come out at once, only a few brave people did. One of the big ways they did it was cooperating with media. There were a lot of documentaries, newspaper articles, and films, plays and much later TV shows. Many of the media accounts were very anti-gay, especially in the early days of the AIDs epidemic.
One of the consequences of some brave folks coming out in public is that other were outed accidently. Joe is gay, oh he hangs out a lot with Bill, I bet Bill is gay also. Eventually after many decades, and many folks accidently outed, American started to accept that your orientation doesn't define you.
Nahhhh just not really necessary to quote me directly. IMHO.omg. you been exploited!
Look at what the author of the article tweeted.Nahhhh just not really necessary to quote me directly. IMHO.
Look at what the author of the article tweeted.
What profession other than sex work, are the workers depicted as victims, drug addicts, STD spreaders, "damaged" psyche, etc? What other profession is shown in the media, where the workers are routinely found murdered as a joke? It's not about "people made fun of the group I'm a part of!" it's about "hey stop putting dehumanizing shit out there that makes people think it's no big deal to harass and kill people who are part of my group".
Look at what the author of the article tweeted.
But what if that is true? Been involved with two sex workers. I was fortunate to dodge any STD's, but the rest of that definitely applied to them.What profession other than sex work, are the workers depicted as victims, drug addicts, STD spreaders, "damaged" psyche, etc?
Are the jokes the cause of the killings? Or are they the result of them?What other profession is shown in the media, where the workers are routinely found murdered as a joke? It's not about "people made fun of the group I'm a part of!" it's about "hey stop putting dehumanizing shit out there that makes people think it's no big deal to harass and kill people who are part of my group".
I think the difference is that the outraged camgirls want to be portrayed to the public as healthy, functioning members of society. Sex workers are not outraged at the use of content without consent. At least, not primarily. If they were, then Camgirlz would have caught flack years ago when they did the same thing. This scandal is the weak spot in HGW that people are using to poke holes in the entire production, but it is not the motivation behind the anger. The anger stems from how sex work is being painted for the eyes of the public. I have not watched the new series so I cannot speak on it's tone. Does it paint a bleak picture of sex work? Does it leave people feeling sad that sex is traded for money? Does it seem detached and impersonal, showing the exchange of resources without any value judgements? Does it feel hopeful? Does it show sex workers smiling/laughing while they interact with clients AND when they turn the cam off?
I think it comes down to people wanting art to speak for them. Does it serve their purposes or not? I remember my friends and I getting backlash for mentioning drugs in our scene in Camgirlz because other women thought it 'was irresponsible' and 'reinforced negative stereotypes'. I actually remember one girl telling us, "I was hoping to use this documentary as a way of coming out to my parents and now I can't because of you."
What profession other than sex work, are the workers depicted as victims, drug addicts, STD spreaders, "damaged" psyche, etc? What other profession is shown in the media, where the workers are routinely found murdered as a joke? It's not about "people made fun of the group I'm a part of!" it's about "hey stop putting dehumanizing shit out there that makes people think it's no big deal to harass and kill people who are part of my group".
I was a child in the 80's so I have no recollection of sex work ever being acceptable in society, but from what I've read, it seems like the AIDS epidemic in the 80's was a big factor as to why society turned on any/all sex workers. And sex workers HAVE been talking to the media, in documentaries, etc for decades. (Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics, Annie Sprinkle, Carol Leigh, etc) Plus during the 80's we there were multiple notorious serial killers (Robert Hansen, the Green River Killer, the Yorkshire Ripper) who specifically targeted sex workers.. I know you said the stigma wasn't so bad for strippers & pornstars, but many strippers and pornstars also did FSSW...
Your "examples" are false equivalencies. Comparing pedophiles and "baby killing murderers" to sex workers? No. If you can't see the difference between the harassment cops and bankers get, vs the type of harassment a sex worker gets...You realize that other professions have negative stereotypes right? Cops are racist, fascist, and power obsessed, soldiers are baby killing murders, who went they get home are just PTSD time bombs waiting to go off and kill everybody, bankers and corporate execs are amoral will do anything for money, politician are power-obssessed habitual liars, with no moral who will do anything to get re-elected. Pedophile, were abused horribly as kids, and now want to do the same to other kids. I am sure if we saw a documentary about pedophiles by pedophiles, they come off in far more positive light, like way they are portrayed on NAMBLA website. But would it be a more accurate picture? I rather doubt it.
As if there haven't been more than a few cam-only women who've been stalked, blackmailed, kidnapped, etc?? I'm going to assume that since you're not a sex worker, you're truly unaware of how often sex workers are targeted because of our jobs.No question that prostitution is a dangerous profession, but camming not so much.
I didn't say anything about the AIDS epidemic stigma being worse for sex workers. What I wrote was reasons I think the why the "pro stripping & pornstar" era of the 80's might have turned sour. In addition, I think gay white cis people were already working in media careers, which paved the way for gay (cis) people being represented in mainstream media, but sex workers historically haven't had that type of media/social power... gay cis people working as actors, writers, directors, etc already had the perfect platform to put themselves in a positive light and reach nearly all of North America. Second-wave feminism also had a big part in turning people against sex work! And yet many sex workers have been vocal about the discrimination we face! Plus lots of us are "out" to our friends and families (not that it's seemed to make much difference socially...)The AIDS backlash was against the homosexual community far more than sex workers.
Salena Storm Discusses 'Hot Girls Wanted: Turned On'
MyFreeCams Model Says Documentary Doesn't Paint Complete Picture:
https://avn.com/business/articles/t...cusses-hot-girls-wanted-turned-on-727425.html
Look at what the author of the article tweeted.
Im not trying to give my opinion. Im trying to contribute to this discussion by forwarding articles about the situation with HGW.Guy, you didn't do your homework. I wasn't joking. We really want you to explain yourself more. I would love to hear more of your opinions. If you could take 5 minutes and give a brief summary of what you read and your take on it. At most 6 sentences.
Got a good game of Telephone going on with some of these articles. This one does go a little more in the direction of what @GenXoxo might be the real reason for the complaints with the series.
You do understand that is exactly what people are complaining about, right?Im not trying to give my opinion. Im trying to contribute to this discussion by forwarding articles about the situation with HGW.
Im not trying to give my opinion. Im trying to contribute to this discussion by forwarding articles about the situation with HGW.
Your "examples" are false equivalencies.
The producers of the porn documentary have been accused of handling the identities of several performers with gross recklessness.
BY JOSEPHINE LIVINGSTONE
April 26, 2017
Where is the line between “fair use” in the legal sense and ethical transgression? As Vocativ reported on Monday, several adult performers have accused the producers of the Netflix documentary series Hot Girls Wanted: Turned On—which is meant to be a sympathetic window into the porn industry—of featuring them without their consent. In one case, the performer’s legal first name was revealed on screen after the producers found her Facebook page.
Gia Paige alleges that she signed a participant release form, then changed her mind about appearing on camera, asking the producers, who include the star Rashida Jones, to cut her. She remained in the final edit. Furthermore, she alleges that the producers used an image of her Facebook page, which at that time included her real first name, without her permission: a dangerous betrayal for a professional at risk of stalking.
The documentary also features cam performers Effy Elizabeth and Autumn Kayy in a Periscope clip. Although the clip is accessible to the public, Elizabeth told Vocativ that having it streamed by Netflix is a different matter. “Everyone is on Netflix,” she said, suggesting that the documentary’s amplification of their performance changed the nature of its presence online. Neither performer was alerted by the producers prior to being featured, they allege.
Went back and watched her part of ep. 3 after reading this article. Here are my personal perceptions.Salena Storm Discusses 'Hot Girls Wanted: Turned On'
MyFreeCams Model Says Documentary Doesn't Paint Complete Picture:
https://avn.com/business/articles/t...cusses-hot-girls-wanted-turned-on-727425.html
Sorry for back to back post, was too late to edit. About this above part of my earlier response.“I treat it like a business. I truly care about what I’m doing and the moves that I’m making and I look into the future before I’m doing something,” she reasons. “I’m also hyper aware of what I’m doing. I don’t do drugs and just understand the opportunity that’s in front of me and I’m trying to take full advantage of it.”
I didn't see anything in her part in the episode that indicated otherwise. She may have been overshadowed, she may not have gotten the spotlight she hoped for (and frankly, I wouldn't have minded seeing more of her featured), but she didn't come across as unprofessional or a drug user.
The original movie is anti-porn propaganda. And Rashida Jones made it and is extremely whorephobic.
I haven't seen the new series but I have seen hot girls wanted. I never took it as "whorephobic"
the film brings to light some of the porn industries' issues. The girls featured were very young and inexperienced. as. fuck. One girl let a pornstar creampie her -last minute- and she was given money to go buy plan b. (Which should not be used as a first method of BC.) She was naive and convinced it was totally safe and normal. The film had a bleak tone because of the girls being so unsure and/or uneducated in the adult industry as well as their own sexualitirs- ending up being taken advantage of, or crossing their boundaries for quick cash.
Not sure if I got the name right there. Anyway, whoever it was.Is it the problem the part where Bonnie Kinz talks about how her stepfather was an avid porn watcher? Or when she talks about how her first exposure to porn came at age 6 or 7, and after that she looked at porn every night, and how she thinks it made her think about sex at a really young age? Or when she talks about how she lost her virginity at age 12, and expresses regret about it? Or is it the claim put forward that 40% of teenagers have seen internet porn by age 14, and 80% of those were not seeking it?
This was just released on the Irish Netflix. Rashida Jones should not be making documentaries at all.
Regardless as to whether she's painting things in a positive or negative light. Documentaries should come from a neutral perspective, not picking individuals and using their individual experiences to represent a whole industry.
Even the online dating episode, she picked some nymphomaniac sleeze bag and used him as an example to represent online dating, she left out people who are now married, people who've started dating someone, when before they were too shy to approach people.
I use this as an example because she did the exact same thing in the original documentary with Porn!
It's not like she has picked random people and done a completely objective view of the industry, she has probably had all the participants screened by a production team and probably a psychologist and picked people who would represent her own personal views.
That's not what a documentary is, or should be. I think the exception was Erica Bliss and Bailey Raine (kind of), both of them were probably included to counteract the negative reception of the initial "documentary".
I admit that the first movie did influence my opinion for a while, especially the scene with the Latino girl in the rape scene,which I found quite disturbing.
Over the last couple weeks I've been reading up on the porn industry and watching other documentaries out of curiosity.
In a nutshell fuck Rashida Jones... She should stick to cheesy comedies.
Unfortunately a lot of porn turns me off so searching through videos it can be hard without making me give up on the experience completely. There is definitely a market for female friendly pornography, and I think men would and could like it too. I find in sex with a good partner the best positions are when we both enjoy it. If I'm not enjoying the position my partner usually isn't either and vice versa. There is probably a biological explanation for this. But if women find sex with men hot and men find sex with women hot then surely there can be a happy compromise in porn where it can be sexy for everyone watching rather than just being aimed at men. I don't think porn will ever really lose its stigma unless you invite everyone in to enjoy its pleasures.