Sorry I thought we were specifically talking about pooped in panties (which are a common request too) for some reason. I gotta start reading from the top down here.
So while I am on CB and MFC, I have had the weird request to sell my panties. I have never been in front of this before and frankly, I don't quite know. What would I sell them for so I do not under value myself? He is a regular of mine and has bought so much of my content on OF, he shows up all the time when I am live on CB. I am comfortable with the idea of selling my underwear, but again it's just a weird request I have never faced. I do not know how much is too little, I would only wear the underwear 1 day and then sell it, or should I wear it longer?
The more days the more expensive. Same for if you are supposed to work out in them or anything. It's really up to you and what you feel comfortable with. But remember to take into aCcount the cost of gas bringing them wherever you plan on posting them, the cost of postage (I've sent some to the Netherlands before, and sending to some places is insanely expensive). A lot of people limit it to inside the US only, if they are US themselves. Be careful mailing to Canada if you are in the US, Holy shit it's expensive! But I digress... Then, take into account your comfortability level with even doing it. Of course you would never put your real return address on it, or anywhere near your home. That's why I say think about gas and time too. Remember post offices put an identifying stamp on them which gives the location of the post office you sent from.
A lot of time you can get prices by weight or a rough idea from google, once you know the destination.
Then the cost to replace the underwear themselves. A lot of these guys like super old, cheap ones. But I have had guys request some of my more luxury wear, and I've charged them accordingly. Then of course there's some I just won't sell at all, for fashion reasons, and they just gotta deal with that.
If it's just a one off thing, to one person, really take into account how comfy you are with it. I've sold them for as little as $40, and as much as $200 so far. If a guy wants me to be wearing them days and days in row, it's gonna be in the hundreds plus all that other stuff. I've sold maybe 20 pairs over the years, but never more than one day in a row for me. I'm just not comfy wearing dirty underwear. One day, and a old pair meh maybe $60 plus postage.
This guy sounds to specifically like
you. So he'll likely pay extra because he wants
yours. But don't mark them up too high, or he'll know you are taking advantage, and he might get butt hurt and storm off.
I would also peep around store fronts on Manyvids, that'll kind of give you an idea of the range people are selling them for too, so you don't have to take anyone's word for it.