I know this is late to the game but I just now came back to this thread to see this
PunkInDrublic said:
But it isn't sacred so whatever you do there isn't disrespectful. It can only be disrespectful if someone finds it sacred.
I'm assuming you're trying to say that's what I'm saying and it not. there are plenty of ways to be disrespectful. (flipping someone off in traffic.. for example) I don't find doing a non-nude show in a library to be any of them. You do. Why is this so hard to understand? Why must I be making an excuse?? I don't really understand.. though at this point I guess this is rhertorical question.
Libraries aren't sacred to me. So no, its not disrespectful to me
In response to the general discussion about 'sacred' things...
If you find someones beliefs harmful/problematic I can understand why you might not see the need to respect their "sacred" space. In the same way that I was being very disrespectful when I was arrested for civil disobedience. I won't go into the full details as they are identity-related but I was arrested many years ago for doing something very disrespectful to get attention for the cause I believe in, and because i felt the entity I was protesting against was dangerous.
All I was trying to share was my personal belief that churches, temples etc.. are sacred to me. That religious iconography is sacred to me. And that I personally won't violate that and it upsets me to do so.
I'm not saying models should cease to do these shows if they disagree.. I just wanted to make that statement
I think it all is really interesting because so much of the time there is no clear answer, its not 100% black and white.. boundries are personal, and blurry.. and steeped in our own sense of what is right and wrong.
There are two important things to think about when planning a 'taboo' show:
1) your conscience. Not PiD's conscience (no matter how much he seems to think that everyone shares his sense of right and wrong, deep down and must just be making excuses about it)
2) If your conscience is ok with it, is it worth the amount of people you may piss off/offend? What about the legal consequences? Are you willing to risk those?
"does this sit right in my soul?"
"is this worth the potential consequences"
If those things come up clear.. then you should do what you damn well please.