I just found my first person whos posts have annoyed me enough to not just skip over them but actually add them to the ignore list. Way to go you!
Familiar with the American educational system it still comes as a surprise to see foreign teaching systems.
Hmmm, I know I never felt the need or desire to physically assault my students to get them to behave in my class.We need this 'discipline freedom' in the US ed. system badly. It used to be this way but then somehow society decided kids had more "rights" than the teacher did to teach and be respected and cooperated with in class. The difference from my generation behaving when getting swats in the principles office was an option, to my kids gen when you cant even touch them to make them leave the room and instead need to call on the school security to do anything, is quite apparent.
Hmmm, I know I never felt the need or desire to physically assault my students to get them to behave in my class.
Yeah, I didn't have school cops to call, and I taught in a "rough" school. It was just me and 20+ teens. Had some tricky situations, but still never needed violence to settle them. My ego is not so fragile that people, especially children, can push me into that by being disrespectful. I mean, that's sort of what kids do.In an ideal situation that's good and should not be necessary. When respect and discipline isn't taught at home and you are continually disrespected and your authority challenged disrupting the ability of others in class to learn,....
These were also obviously somewhere they don't have school cops to handle all the internal issues and the kids mentality of "I can do anything i want and you cant do shit to stop me." Life is all about respect of the elders and your fellow man. You reap what you sew.
And I will never automatically respect someone just because they are older than me. Respect is earned, not granted simply because you've been on this earth a little longer. I live in the south, a huge chunk of the older population here is incredibly racist, sexist, homophobic and elitist. These people do not deserve my respect, considering this world will be a better place once they're out if it.
I fundamentally disagree with this mindset. I will respect everyone until they do something to lose that respect. Rather then respect no one until they have earned it and thats regardless of age.
Had some tricky situations, but still never needed violence to settle them.
If I didn't need to resort to violence to remove angry weapon-wielding men from the (public) library I worked at, I think it's generally always going to be uncalled for in a classroom.
don't do anything to actually help the conversation advance. Thank you to those of you who have kept a level head throughout this. Because it IS a very personal subject, and it DOES have a big effect on our emotions, it's easy to slip up and say something hurtful without meaning to.It's really not that hard to figure out when you're not super small minded.
Whoa, whoa, whoa. Ok, first of all, we can have this discussion while staying civil and not resorting to name-calling simply because there are differing opinions. Things like this
don't do anything to actually help the conversation advance. Thank you to those of you who have kept a level head throughout this. Because it IS a very personal subject, and it DOES have a big effect on our emotions, it's easy to slip up and say something hurtful without meaning to.
@AerynShade
No, I don't think that children should be beaten. BUT I do think that teachers are so afraid of the repercussions (getting fired) that they are forced to allow the hooligans to disrespect them and other students. One of my teacher friends frequently has "bad kids" throwing spitballs/books/desks at her for fun....
My patience for outdated thinking (especially ideas like this that have been disproven by real science) is very thin. Geographically, I'm surrounded by people who think it will be totally okay to beat their children with belts, simply because their parents did it to them. This line of reasoning is toxic and damages one of the most vulnerable classes in our society.
The fact that teachers used to be able to beat children with swats, paddles and/or an open hand is nothing but horrifying.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/moral-landscapes/201309/research-spanking-it-s-bad-all-kids
Gunnoe’s findings, announced this week: “The claims made for not spanking children fail to hold up. They are not consistent with the data.”
Those who were physically disciplined performed better than those who weren’t in a whole series of categories, including school grades, an optimistic outlook on life, the willingness to perform volunteer work, and the ambition to attend college, Gunnoe found. And they performed no worse than those who weren’t spanked in areas like early sexual activity, getting into fights, and becoming depressed. She found little difference between the sexes or races.
A key focus of the work of Jason M. Fuller of the University of Akron Law School was Sweden, which 30 years ago became the first nation to impose a complete ban on physical discipline and is in many respects “an ideal laboratory to study spanking bans,” according to Fuller.
Since the spanking ban, child abuse rates in Sweden have exploded over 500 percent, according to police reports. Even just one year after the ban took effect, and after a massive government public education campaign, Fuller found that “not only were Swedish parents resorting to pushing, grabbing, and shoving more than U.S. parents, but they were also beating their children twice as often.”
After a decade of the ban, “rates of physical child abuse in Sweden had risen to three times the U.S. rate” and “from 1979 to 1994, Swedish children under seven endured an almost six-fold increase in physical abuse,” Fuller’s analysis revealed.
For instance, after Sweden outlawed spanking, violent behavior did not decrease. Instead, there has been substantially more violence in Sweden than ever before—violence by children, violence by parents, and violence by society in general.
So, the ban has not made youth behavior any better. And now, it seems that many Swedish parents feel they can “neither control the child’s behavior nor tolerate its effect upon themselves.” Some even appear unable to resist “explosive attacks of rage” against their own kids. Within ten years of the ban, physical child abuse had risen to three times the U.S. rate. And in the thirty years since the ban, child abuse has increased by over 1400%, even though the Swedish population has only increased by about 11.5%. Thus, Sweden’s experience since outlawing spanking has been largely inconsistent with its nonviolent goals.
At the other end of the spectrum is Singapore. It is common to hear spanking opponents claim that, “although physical punishment may produce conformity in the immediate situation, in the longer run, it tends to increase the probability of deviance, including delinquency in adolescence and violent crime inside and outside the family as an adult.” Some even say that “corporal punishment disadvantages children cognitively.” If true, we would expect to see these problems where spanking is prevalent, like in Singapore. There, schoolteachers corporally punish unruly students, parents cane their children, and the government whips adults as criminal punishment. If the anti-spanking position were valid, Singapore would be one of the most violent and academically deficient societies on the planet. Instead, it is the opposite. Despite the fact that Singapore’s population has risen by 27% in the past ten years, their crime rates have dropped—both per capita and in total.
At the same time, Singaporean schoolchildren have done very well on international academic tests—taking second and third place in math, and first place in science.
Granted, Singapore’s authoritarian culture may not interest everyone. But it does show that the spanking-is-always-harmful position does not stand up to casual scrutiny.
The contrast between Sweden and Singapore may be somewhat confusing, because of widely advertised claims that corporal punishment is “associated with higher rates of aggression . . . .”
The problem is that these claims, though widely advertised, are seldom based on sound scientific research. Rather, professional methodologists have found that anti-spanking studies are often structured to support the researcher’s personal philosophy, instead of being structured to fairly analyze the results of physical discipline.
To start, many anti-spanking researchers begin with a conclusion, not a hypothesis. Take Dr. Murray Straus, one of the world’s leading spanking opponents. He admits that his goal is to prove that physical discipline, “by itself, has harmful psychological side effects for children and hurts society as a whole.”
Similarly, a review of the research indicates that over 80% of the corporal punishment articles are “merely opinion-driven editorials, reviews or commentaries, devoid of new empirical findings.” Thus, when methodologists try to gain a comprehensive understanding of the research, they have to filter out most of the articles.
Many of the remaining studies are still unreliable. Some have not passed peer-review. Others do not compare corporal punishment to any other punishments, which does not allow for meaningful analysis. Still others mainly research extreme violence—like beating someone with a strap—and then assume that the results apply to a mild slap on the hand.
The studies that do not have these problems show “no evidence for unique detrimental effects of normative physical punishment.” Instead, they tend to show that spanking is either harmless or beneficial, depending on the context. That is, the effects of physical discipline depend on things like the overall parenting style, the accompanying use of explanation and reason, and the child’s age.
Saw a picture of a model pretending to be a Thanksgiving turkey. Oiled up, hands and feet bound, apple in mouth, in a fake oven, with veggies all around and in her.
First thought? "Psh, who adds bell peppers to their roast turkey trimmings?"
I think I might be a bit desensitized to porn.
Muki's Kitchen?
http://mukiskitchen.com/free1.html
It was a retweet of a model, didn't say the site. But the table/oven setup looks the same. Huh. So this is a thing. Okay.