So, I'm gonna Jump in here and add my .02, as my self. I'm the bigfoot in the equation with Phoenix. I've been active on CB, mostly as a moderator and free tech help guy since 2013. I don't work for CB. In the last short while, CB has become awful about arbitrary bans. I've seen models band for no other reason than kicking someone from their room for badgering them and generally being a dick, and when the dickhead goes and complains, because he tipped, the model gets banned. Guilt before innocence.
The verification bans are obviously just a computer that's been programmed to instantly ban any account to upload ID, until that ID is verified. Got it. Tell people that when they submit. Phoenix never tried to broadcast before verification, nor did anyone else come in the room or appear on cam with her.
As far as the spiel about "you've been verified in a room before so you don't get the NEW tag." Bullshit. She had it the first night. Not to mention, how about maevesucks, formerly minxymaeve? She had several hundred thousand followers, killed her account, and I'll be damned if she didn't get that NEW tag for 7 days.
Probably just shut the account down and start over, knowing now to wait for the verification to be done for several days before clicking broadcast that first time.