Nordling said:13/13 But gosh, that question near the end about gender was REALLY tough!
:lol:
southsamurai said:the BSG word is actually frak, not frack lol
And technically both are incorrect when it comes to the actual process. Hydraulic Fracturing is shortened to Fraccing by people in the industry who actually deal with the process. The mass media incorrectly spell it with a K.emptiedglass said:southsamurai said:the BSG word is actually frak, not frack lol
They're phonetically identical, so there. :tongue2:
Oh I'm sure the media will keep spelling it that way but it's not a new term by any means. The first fraccing job was in 1947 so the 'k' variation is way late to the game.Nordling said:Heh. When a new term is coined, like a shortened form of an existing term...I'm not sure who gets the honors to be "correct."
By using the same pronunciation as "flaccid," which has the same pattern of spelling, then we'd say "frack-sing" when pronouncing "fraccing." I'm guessing that the media spelling, "fracking," will ultimately win in the spelling wars.
And in this case, it doesn't really matter, since neither spelling is currently in the dictionary--well, at least not the American Heritage. It sounds like when the "nickname" was first used, it was within a very limited audience. So, it's slang or lingo--I don't think we can argue about "technical" correctness.JerryBoBerry said:Oh I'm sure the media will keep spelling it that way but it's not a new term by any means. The first fraccing job was in 1947 so the 'k' variation is way late to the game.Nordling said:Heh. When a new term is coined, like a shortened form of an existing term...I'm not sure who gets the honors to be "correct."
By using the same pronunciation as "flaccid," which has the same pattern of spelling, then we'd say "frack-sing" when pronouncing "fraccing." I'm guessing that the media spelling, "fracking," will ultimately win in the spelling wars.
Nordling said:And in this case, it doesn't really matter, since neither spelling is currently in the dictionary--well, at least not the American Heritage. It sounds like when the "nickname" was first used, it was within a very limited audience. So, it's slang or lingo--I don't think we can argue about "technical" correctness.JerryBoBerry said:Oh I'm sure the media will keep spelling it that way but it's not a new term by any means. The first fraccing job was in 1947 so the 'k' variation is way late to the game.Nordling said:Heh. When a new term is coined, like a shortened form of an existing term...I'm not sure who gets the honors to be "correct."
By using the same pronunciation as "flaccid," which has the same pattern of spelling, then we'd say "frack-sing" when pronouncing "fraccing." I'm guessing that the media spelling, "fracking," will ultimately win in the spelling wars.
"Why the fracking hell does it matter how we spell it?"LadyLuna said:Nordling said:And in this case, it doesn't really matter, since neither spelling is currently in the dictionary--well, at least not the American Heritage. It sounds like when the "nickname" was first used, it was within a very limited audience. So, it's slang or lingo--I don't think we can argue about "technical" correctness.JerryBoBerry said:Oh I'm sure the media will keep spelling it that way but it's not a new term by any means. The first fraccing job was in 1947 so the 'k' variation is way late to the game.Nordling said:Heh. When a new term is coined, like a shortened form of an existing term...I'm not sure who gets the honors to be "correct."
By using the same pronunciation as "flaccid," which has the same pattern of spelling, then we'd say "frack-sing" when pronouncing "fraccing." I'm guessing that the media spelling, "fracking," will ultimately win in the spelling wars.
False- it is in discussions like this that things get solidified to the point where they ARE added to the dictionaries.
I propose the following:
fraccing- the process as referred to by people in the field or people with a strong interest in the field, scientifically correct
fracking- the process as referred to by people outside the field, correct in non-technical writings
fraking- the BSG term with a different meaning entirely
Ha! Don't forget "fracing."LadyLuna said:Nordling said:And in this case, it doesn't really matter, since neither spelling is currently in the dictionary--well, at least not the American Heritage. It sounds like when the "nickname" was first used, it was within a very limited audience. So, it's slang or lingo--I don't think we can argue about "technical" correctness.JerryBoBerry said:Oh I'm sure the media will keep spelling it that way but it's not a new term by any means. The first fraccing job was in 1947 so the 'k' variation is way late to the game.Nordling said:Heh. When a new term is coined, like a shortened form of an existing term...I'm not sure who gets the honors to be "correct."
By using the same pronunciation as "flaccid," which has the same pattern of spelling, then we'd say "frack-sing" when pronouncing "fraccing." I'm guessing that the media spelling, "fracking," will ultimately win in the spelling wars.
False- it is in discussions like this that things get solidified to the point where they ARE added to the dictionaries.
I propose the following:
fraccing- the process as referred to by people in the field or people with a strong interest in the field, scientifically correct
fracking- the process as referred to by people outside the field, correct in non-technical writings
fraking- the BSG term with a different meaning entirely
Ha ha! Doesn't. lol I also predict that no matter what happens, and no matter what becomes the "dictionary entry of choice," the average MFC member will forever spell it differently than whatever that turns out to be. :lol:Rose said:"Why the fracking hell does it matter how we spell it?"LadyLuna said:Nordling said:And in this case, it doesn't really matter, since neither spelling is currently in the dictionary--well, at least not the American Heritage. It sounds like when the "nickname" was first used, it was within a very limited audience. So, it's slang or lingo--I don't think we can argue about "technical" correctness.JerryBoBerry said:Oh I'm sure the media will keep spelling it that way but it's not a new term by any means. The first fraccing job was in 1947 so the 'k' variation is way late to the game.Nordling said:Heh. When a new term is coined, like a shortened form of an existing term...I'm not sure who gets the honors to be "correct."
By using the same pronunciation as "flaccid," which has the same pattern of spelling, then we'd say "frack-sing" when pronouncing "fraccing." I'm guessing that the media spelling, "fracking," will ultimately win in the spelling wars.
False- it is in discussions like this that things get solidified to the point where they ARE added to the dictionaries.
I propose the following:
fraccing- the process as referred to by people in the field or people with a strong interest in the field, scientifically correct
fracking- the process as referred to by people outside the field, correct in non-technical writings
fraking- the BSG term with a different meaning entirely
Nordling said:Ha ha! Doesn't. lol I also predict that no matter what happens, and no matter what becomes the "dictionary entry of choice," the average MFC member will forever spell it differently than whatever that turns out to be. :lol:Rose said:"Why the fracking hell does it matter how we spell it?"LadyLuna said:Nordling said:And in this case, it doesn't really matter, since neither spelling is currently in the dictionary--well, at least not the American Heritage. It sounds like when the "nickname" was first used, it was within a very limited audience. So, it's slang or lingo--I don't think we can argue about "technical" correctness.JerryBoBerry said:Oh I'm sure the media will keep spelling it that way but it's not a new term by any means. The first fraccing job was in 1947 so the 'k' variation is way late to the game.
False- it is in discussions like this that things get solidified to the point where they ARE added to the dictionaries.
I propose the following:
fraccing- the process as referred to by people in the field or people with a strong interest in the field, scientifically correct
fracking- the process as referred to by people outside the field, correct in non-technical writings
fraking- the BSG term with a different meaning entirely