I don't think that people are disputing whether it's appreciated or not. This discussion started about what people consider over-reactions to tips they feel are smaller than what they consider to be appropriate tips. I don't think anyone has said that we shouldn't be thankful for smaller tips, just that some people adjust their reactions based on the size of the tip.
Most of us models agree that we appreciate 1 token or 100 tokens, since every one is a nickel we didn't have before that adds up in the grand scheme of it. Girls just have different reactions to those single tokens. Some squee over it, others give a simple "thank you" and others may do a jump-for-joy, but they all appreciate it. It's those different reactions that make us unique, since we all process things on MFC differently, and run our rooms differently, and promote ourselves differently.
If you genuinely get as visibly excited for $1 or less as you do for $100, then that's awesome!
But I do like to put myself in the tipper's shoes. Lots of us are putting ourselves in the "small tipper's shoes" but don't forget to put yourself in the "big tipper's shoes" as well...
When I drop a 1000 tip on the girl I am watching, I get excited about her reaction. In many peoples' opinions, 1000 is a large tip, so we may expect some sort of elevated reaction to it. It's a rush for me to tip relatively big and get a relatively big reaction. So after I drop the 1000 and see the excitement, and then moments later, the girl gets a 1 or 5 token tip, and has the SAME amount of excitement for it, it does feel a little disappointing for me. While I am still very happy to have made her day better by sharing so many tokens with her, I am sad that this other person, only dropping a dime or 50 cents, gets the same reaction.
So we think we are being more gracious and inclusive when we have grand reactions to the small tippers, but in a sense we may be disappointing others at the same time.
Whew, I know that was a LOT of thinking really far into it, but since we're in a big discussion about it, I figured I'd write all that out.
I posted earlier in the thread that "in a nutshell": All tips big or small are appreciated and we should thank them all. The level of excitement for each sized tip will vary from girl to girl.