I completely understand where you're coming from with this. As a member before you spend tokens on things you do want to know if the "product" is good and worth it. I for sure look at reviews on Amazon before buying and those ranks matter to me. All 1 star? I'm not going anywhere near it. Giant cat tree with very few bad ratings but mostly 5 stars? It's mine. So on a cam site I could see how you would want one too. Even some semblance of one. And asking her room if a vid is worth it doesnt help much. Of course her fans will say it's great. It's why I suggested making it only be possible to rate if people spent money on the girl herself. It solves that mostly.
On a lot of sites you can get ratings removed if they are obviously just mean and vindictive or out of place. Even on SM. Since this site is not offering that then there should be a way to limit it so assholes just arent abusing the system. Scenario: Take MFC top 20 for instance. The fans are rabid at times trying to get their girl higher and higher in ranks. They do a lot of things trying to mess with her "competition." If they knew they could all just go rank her badly to mess up her placement and help their fav girl out you know dang well they would in droves and try to get others to the site to do the same. Scenario 2: A girl pops on her first night and is met with the trove of guys who seek out new girls. Each one of them knows the system and demands free content, flashes, etc or they will down rate her and destroy her possibilities on the site before she's even had one night on the site.
I think we can all agree neither of these are really fair for the models in any way. The only way to even halfway prevent it is to make it so only tippers to her can rate her at all. It cuts off a lot of abuse in the system from douches. Rating her bad just for not being a blonde which he prefers would even happen. Now of course tippers are not saints or above abusing the system as well so making it so they have to tip her to rate her helps as well. Abusers with money are even less likely to tip just to rate bad. However there will still be some who do. In that instance the girls seeing who rated them what would come in to play and her being able to report a guy for rating her badly without reason would happen. And yes a lot of guys take models private on SM and demand things she told them NO to and will leave a bad rating for it. It's messed up so again girls can get those removed. Pretty easy then.
I do think there should be some system in place for members to be able to tell in some way if the model is a good one or not as we all know some girls are scammers as well. Having tippers only helps the girl in many ways and gives members a general idea that she comes through on her promises while keeping away from the bad eggs in the bunch. Members deserve protection too. So maybe there is a meet in the middle compromise to protect members and models and having it be tippers only is it or does anyone else have another suggestion that's better? I'm by no means saying my idea is the only idea or good one.
Maybe another idea is having ratings on her content at least You buy one of her vids and you get to rate or comment on it for instance. This would be a really cool feature to have. Off the top of my head no cam site does this. Might be a good idea though? Again only tippers could rate or comment but it would at the least tell members if content is worth buying and give them a taste of the model as well. If she describes as 10 minutes of all dildo play and it turns out to be just that he can give her a 5 star and comment how it's as described or hot or whatever. Helps the model sell more and gives other members an idea if they wanna buy it. If it turns out to be 8 minutes of talking and 2 minutes of play he can give a 1 star and comment how it's not what she said it was at all. This helps other members as a heads up to stay away from that vid and hurts the model from selling more vids with false advertising, as it should be. Also if model fails to ever give a password to member (scammy scammer style) a member could rate and comment as well again helping others on the site. Just an idea though and something that could be kept in mind for launch or to be implemented later on if people like it.